Stagnation Assassins case studies grade turnarounds on the record, not the legend. The newest series rebuilds results from 10-K and 20-F filings: Gerstner’s first three years at IBM, Xerox from 2000 to 2003, Kmart after bankruptcy, J.C. Penney in fiscal 2012, J.Crew after its March 2011 buyout, 3M’s efficiency years, Nintendo’s FY2015 operating recovery and Toyota’s fiscal 2010 recall costs. Each one separates what the filings show from what they don’t, and a companion piece explains why a flow-through ratio stops working when the growth denominator shrinks.
Alongside the filings work you’ll find operator reads of Lowe’s and Home Depot, customer-friction teardowns of Trader Joe’s, Disney, Apple, IKEA, Planet Fitness and Aldi, and award-style roundups of leaders and companies whose moves line up with the HOT System’s 10 principles. Start with the filings series if you want the method; start with the teardowns if you want ideas you can test on your own customers this week.
Todd’s own roundup on toddhagopian.com: Turnaround Case Studies: What Actually Worked.
Filings series: turnarounds graded from the record
- Toyota Fiscal 2010: Separating Recall Costs, an Estimate Change, and Lost Sales in the Filings — Toyota booked ¥257 billion for recalls in fiscal 2010; only ¥89 billion was the four famous recalls. A 20-F bridge of repairs, an estimate change, lost sales.
- 3M 2000–2007: Did the Efficiency Program Show Up as an Innovation Fade in the Filings? — 3M’s 10-Ks for 1999–2008: R&D fell from 6.7% to about 5.6% of sales, capex was cut and restored, and margins held. What the filings show and don’t.
- J.Crew After the March 2011 LBO: What the First Filings Show (and What They Don’t) — J.Crew’s filings after its March 2011 buyout: $1,600M of new debt, interest paid up from $1.1M to $99.2M, capex up, and a slowdown that predated the deal.
- J.C. Penney Fiscal 2012: A Market Slump, or a Company That Left Its Customers? — J.C. Penney’s comparable sales fell 25.2% in fiscal 2012 while Macy’s rose 3.7%, Kohl’s 0.3% and Nordstrom 7.3%. What the 10-Ks show about slump vs. company.
- Five Evidence Tests Before You Applaud a Turnaround: Kmart as the Negative Case — Kmart earned $1.1 billion after bankruptcy while comparable sales fell 11%. Five evidence tests, run on its SEC filings, separate a real turnaround from a rebound.
- When the Growth Denominator Shrinks, Stop Trusting the Ratio — Flow-through tested on HP, DEC, Unisys and IBM filings, FY1993–96: when the ratio works, when it hits 3,681%, and four checks before it goes on a dashboard.
- Iwata’s FY2014–2015 Nintendo: Operating Recovery Is Not a Complete CEO Grade — Nintendo’s FY2015 turn to operating profit, rebuilt from filings: a trough base year, smaller write-downs, a ¥24bn yen lift and cash from an inventory sell-down.
- Xerox 2000–2003: Three Bridges Before You Call It a Turnaround — Xerox’s 10-Ks rebuilt: a $3.6B recapitalization, a restatement that moved revenue into 2002–03, and margins that rose while sales kept falling.
- Starbucks’ Oct 29 Results: Traffic, Ticket, and the China Accounting Bridge — Comps up 7.2%, revenue down 4.5%. A segment bridge of Starbucks’ Oct 29 results separates North America recovery from the China deal and smaller charges.
- Gerstner’s First Three Years: Grade the Decisions, Not the Legend — A rubric grade of IBM’s 1993-1995 recovery from 10-K data, peer controls, and pension and restructuring adjustments. Provisional B, on the B/C line.
Customer-friction teardowns
- Disney Deleted Free FastPass and Sold It Back — Disney killed free FastPass, then sold the relief back as Lightning Lane — three tiers, surge pricing, $449 a day. The paywall isn’t the sin. The vanished goodwill is.
- Aldi’s Cart Deposit: The Hidden Cost of the Quarter — Aldi’s 25-cent cart deposit and no-free-bags model built an empire, but in 2026 it quietly shrinks the basket. A teardown and the fix.
- IKEA’s Labyrinth Punishes the Decided Buyer — IKEA’s labyrinth and flat-pack built a furniture empire — and shoppers love the maze. So why does it punish the buyer who already decided? The friction is undifferentiated.
- Planet Fitness Bet You’d Never Show Up — Planet Fitness removed every barrier to signing up — then built a wall around the exit. The $10 gym’s real problem isn’t price. It’s where the friction lives.
- Trader Joe’s Won #1 By Refusing Everything — Trader Joe’s became America’s #1 grocer by refusing delivery, apps, and loyalty. The refusals won. But one blindspot remains — it knows nothing about its own cult.
- Apple’s $19 Gap: The Charger It Won’t Include — Apple pulled the charger for the planet — and kept the margin. The cost and carbon win was real. The unboxing gap it dropped on customers wasn’t. A teardown.
Operator reads and leader roundups
- Lowe’s $10B Bet: Failing Wall Street Test — Lowe’s spent $10.1B on FBM and ADG, suspended buybacks, took the EPS hit. Wall Street grades the quarter. Lowe’s grades the decade.
- Is Home Depot Stagnating? 8-Quarter Read — Eight-quarter operator diagnosis of Home Depot through the Right-to-Win lens. Pro pivot wins, core retail drifts. What HD’s May 19 print reveals.
- Top 25 Transformation Executives in the Fortune 500: Real-World Leaders Exemplifying the HOT System Principles — Discover how top executives apply HOT System principles to drive business transformation and growth.
- The 80/20 Excellence Awards: Organizations Achieving Maximum Impact with Minimum Complexity — Explore how organizations achieve maximum impact and minimize complexity using the HOT System’s revolutionary 80/20² approach in this detailed analysis.
- The Transformation Leadership Awards: 25 Non-Fortune 500 CEOs Who Delivered 10X+ Results Through HOT System Principles — Discover how 25 non-Fortune 500 CEOs achieved extraordinary results by unknowingly applying the principles of Todd Hagopian’s HOT System.
- The Continuous Improvement Champions: Companies Completing 50+ Improvements Annually
- The Orthodoxy Breaker Awards: 4 CEOs Who Exemplify HOT System Principles in Traditional Industries
- 10 Manufacturing CEOs Who Unknowingly Applied HOT System Principles to Achieve Breakthrough Results — Discover how manufacturing leaders achieved breakthrough results by unknowingly applying HOT system principles without ever hearing of it.
- The Rapid Transformation Awards: Fastest Business Turnarounds in History
Related topics
- Stagnation Diagnosis and Pattern Recognition
- Transformation Roadmaps and Execution
- Innovation and Orthodoxy Breaking
Go further
- Book Todd to speak: bring these ideas to your leadership team or conference. toddhagopian.com/speaking
- Read the books: Stagnation Assassin, plus the forthcoming 10-Minute Transformation (Koehler Books, February 23, 2027). toddhagopian.com/book/
